Raise awareness of environmental health issues in order to better protect our children and future generations.

EMF Studies

12 April 2017

India: Man Claims Cell Tower Gave Him Cancer, Supreme Court Shuts It Down

The tower will be the 1st to be closed on an individual’s petition alleging harmful radiation.

Man claims cell tower gave him cancer, Supreme Court shuts it down
by Dhananjay Mahapatra,TNN, 
12 April 2017

HIGHLIGHTS

  • A 42-year-old domestic help moved the SC complaining that a BSNL tower illegally installed on a neighbour’s rooftop had exposed him to harmful radiation for 14 yrs.
  • The bench in its order said, “We direct that the particular mobile tower shall be deactivated by BSNL within 7 days from today.”
  • The tower will be the 1st to be closed on an individual’s petition alleging harmful radiation.


NEW DELHI: A 42-year-old domestic help will go down in history as the man who persuaded the Supreme Court to shut down a mobile phone tower on the ground that its electromagnetic radiation+ afflicted him with cancer.

Last year, Harish Chand Tiwari, who works at the residence of Prakash Sharma in the Dal Bazar area of Gwalior, moved the SC through advocate Nivedita Sharma, complaining that a BSNL tower illegally installed on a neighbour's rooftop in 2002 had exposed him to harmful radiation 24x7 for the last 14 years.

The order is likely to further fuel the debate over the effects of radiation from mobile phone towers+ with a section of activists feeling vindicated while the government argues there is no evidence to prove that the waves cause cancer.

Radiation from the BSNL tower, less than 50 metres from the house where he worked, afflicted him with Hodgkin's Lymphoma caused by continuous and prolonged exposure to radiation, Tiwari complained.

In a recent order, a bench of Justices Ranjan Gogoi and Navin Sinha said, "We direct that the particular mobile tower shall be deactivated by BSNL within seven days from today." The tower will be the first to be closed on an individual's petition alleging harmful radiation.

The SC, which began hearing the issue relating to radiation from cell towers from March 18 last year, had asked the parties to file additional documents to show that radiation from such towers were harmful to humans and animals+ .

Private petitioners have been predicting disastrous consequences in the future.

Activists have alleged that radiation from mushrooming mobile phone towers have caused sparrows, crows and bees to vanish.

But the Cellular Operators Association of India and the Union government have vehemently denied the allegations and said such fears were unfounded and that no scientific study had conclusively linked mobile phone tower radiation to cancer or vanishing of sparrows, crows and bees.

The department of telecom (DoT) in its affidavit before the SC in October last year had said that of the over 12 lakh mobile phone towers in the country, it had tested 3.30 lakh towers.

It said only 212 towers were found exceeding radiation limits and they were fined Rs 10 lakh. It said so far Rs 10 crore was collected from different cellular operators as penalty.

DoT had relied upon a World Health Organisation (WHO) report as well as over 25,000 articles in the past 30 years to say that there was no confirmation of "any health consequences from exposure to low level electromagnetic fields".

In 2014, a parliamentary committee had recommended to the Union government to carry out a scientific study by a reputed government agency on impact of telecommunication and mobile phone towers and handsets on humans. Private petitioners had alleged that no such study had been undertaken.

But the DoT had informed the court that the Centre had constituted an expert committee to study the possible impact of electromagnetic field radiation+ on living beings.

No comments:

Post a Comment